You can read Liam's recent speeches and questions below by following the links.
I shall be brief, Presiding Officer. Does the cabinet secretary not accept that he has made my point for me?
Yes, I do. From what I have seen, there is a broad range of opinion on the matter, as I am sure Rona Mackay will agree.
Does the member not see that there is an issue on that point?
Will the cabinet secretary give way?
Will the cabinet secretary give any timescale for that?
I am not sure that we did know that. We do not know exactly how many submissions there are yet because of the sheer volume of them.
That is a very important point.
I am not sure that that was an answer to my question.
Yesterday’s programme for government mentioned the Hate Crime and Public Order (Scotland) Bill, but it failed to mention the bill’s costs