If Mr Neil’s Government can spend millions more on bus passes, why has it not been able to find only £15 million to support much-needed r

Will the member take an intervention?

Can I take it from that that the member thinks that it is okay not to pass on the full £96 million in Barnett consequentials to Police Sc

The cabinet secretary needs to accept that the Scottish budget is up in real terms from when the SNP came to power.

Will the cabinet secretary address another statistic: that non-pay spending in Scotland is 12.5 per cent of the revenue budget whereas th

The member has chosen her data rather selectively.

I thank the cabinet secretary for that information.

Will the member take an intervention?

rose —

Will the member take an intervention?