I hear the point that John Finnie makes, and I understand it. However, such an approach would be new to Scotland.

I really cannot. I am in my final minute.

Does Rona Mackay think it is acceptable that SNP-run Glasgow City Council’s latest antisocial behaviour strategy is dated 2005-08?

We rightly spend a great deal of time in the chamber discussing high-profile crimes, but we rarely discuss something that is lower level,

That is about perceptions. The minister must go out into communities and find out what is really happening on the ground.

Will the member take an intervention?

Effective broadband is clearly crucial to entrepreneurship, whether the business is starting up or scaling up.

Police Scotland has been plagued by financial troubles since the SNP created it, despite the Scottish Conservatives getting back the VAT

Will the member take an intervention?

Recent timetable changes mean that Montrose is now a major interchange station, but the facilities for passengers are totally inadequate,